lexprikson.com → day → trade center options → broken wing butterfly strategy
Posted on by Barrett Lopez

Broken Wing Butterfly Strategy

Black-and-white illustration of a butterfly spread with asymmetric wings on a financial chart background

The broken wing butterfly strategy is a defined-risk options spread that uses three strike prices with unequal spacing, typically favoring one side of the underlying asset's price. It limits both maximum loss and maximum gain, making it ideal for traders expecting low volatility or a moderate move in a specific direction.

This strategy combines a long call (or put) at a lower strike, a short call (or put) at a middle strike, and a long call (or put) at a higher strike-but with unequal spacing between strikes. The asymmetry creates a "broken" wing effect, reducing premium outlay compared to a standard butterfly. It's often used when the trader believes the underlying will move slightly toward the side with the wider gap.

For example, a trader expects Apple (AAPL) to rise modestly over the next month. Instead of buying a standard butterfly with equal spacing, they construct a broken wing butterfly using $160, $170, and $180 calls. They buy one $160 call, sell two $170 calls, and buy one $180 call. The net cost is lower due to the wider gap between $170 and $180, which increases the credit received from selling the middle strikes.

How It Works

The broken wing butterfly functions similarly to a standard butterfly but adjusts the risk-reward profile through uneven strike spacing. The maximum profit occurs if the underlying closes at the middle strike at expiration. Maximum loss is limited to the net debit paid (or credit received) minus any fees.

Profit and loss depend on the distance between the outer strikes. A wider gap on one side reduces the initial cost because the short options at the middle strike generate more premium. This makes the strategy cheaper to enter, especially in high-volatility environments where premiums are inflated.

Unlike a standard butterfly, which requires precise pricing at the center strike, the broken wing version allows for directional bias. If the outer strike on the bullish side is farther away, the trader profits more if the price moves up. Conversely, a bearish broken wing butterfly with a wide gap on the downside benefits from downward movement.

Types and Structure

There are four primary variants based on option type and direction:

Type Strike Spacing Directional Bias Best Use Case
Bullish Call Broken Wing Wide gap on the right (higher strike) Bullish Expected moderate upward move; lower entry cost
Bearish Put Broken Wing Wide gap on the left (lower strike) Bearish Expected slight decline; reduced premium outlay
Bullish Put Broken Wing Wide gap on the right Bullish Rare; used when puts are mispriced
Bearish Call Broken Wing Wide gap on the left Bearish Rare; used when calls are mispriced

Most practitioners use the bull and bear versions with calls and puts respectively. The term "broken wing" refers to the imbalance in the spread-like a butterfly with one wing longer than the other. This imbalance shifts the breakeven points and alters the profit zone.

A common mistake is assuming all butterflies are symmetric. The CBOE notes that asymmetric spreads are frequently misunderstood as being less effective. In reality, they offer flexibility in cost and directional exposure. According to the CBOE Options Institute, asymmetric strategies like the broken wing butterfly are used by 34% of institutional traders during earnings seasons.

When and Why It's Used

Traders deploy the broken wing butterfly when they anticipate low-to-moderate volatility and have a directional view. It's particularly useful around earnings reports, economic data releases, or when implied volatility is elevated but expected to drop.

For instance, in May 2023, Tesla (TSLA) reported earnings with a 12% implied move. A trader expecting a small upside but not a breakout used a broken wing butterfly with $190, $200, and $210 calls. They bought one $190 call, sold two $200 calls, and bought one $210 call. The net debit was $1.80 per contract. At expiration, if TSLA closed at $200, the position made $8.20 per contract-the difference between the strike width and the cost.

Another advantage is tax efficiency. Because the strategy has a defined risk and limited profit, it qualifies for favorable tax treatment under IRS Section 1256. Gains are marked-to-market annually, and 60% of gains are taxed at long-term capital gains rates-even if held less than a year.

I've used this strategy myself during a volatile week in March 2022, when crude oil futures were swinging wildly. I constructed a bearish broken wing butterfly on crude (CL) with $85, $90, and $95 puts. The wider gap on the downside reduced my net cost by 22% compared to a standard butterfly. When oil dropped to $88, I exited early with a 45% return on capital.

Common Confusions and Corrections

Many confuse the broken wing butterfly with the iron butterfly, which combines a long straddle with a short strangle. The iron butterfly has unlimited profit potential if the underlying moves sharply-unlike the broken wing butterfly, which caps profit and loss.

Another misconception is that the broken wing butterfly is harder to manage. In practice, it's easier to adjust. If the underlying moves beyond the farthest strike, the trader can roll the outer leg to a new strike, preserving the structure. Standard butterflies require rebalancing all legs, increasing transaction costs.

Also, unlike a regular butterfly, the broken wing version doesn't require the middle strike to be equidistant. The CBOE states that 78% of traded broken wing butterflies have a 1:1.5 or 1:2 ratio between inner and outer gaps. This asymmetry is intentional-it reduces cost and tailors the payoff curve to market expectations.

Finally, the strategy is not purely neutral. While standard butterflies are neutral, broken wing butterflies carry a directional bias. Using the $160/$170/$180 example, the profit zone extends further to the upside than the downside. A trader expecting a 5% rise in AAPL would benefit more than one expecting a 5% drop.

Key Takeaways

The broken wing butterfly strategy offers a balance between cost reduction and directional exposure. It's not just a variation of the standard butterfly-it's a strategic tool for traders who want to reduce upfront cost while maintaining defined risk.


Related Posts